File 017

Ten Natural Phenomena That Sound Made Up

Some natural phenomena sound made up: a glacier that bleeds, an icicle that freezes the seafloor, a lake where lightning flashes almost every night. This file collects ten of the strangest, and checks what science actually knows about each. Several were genuine mysteries until recently, and a couple still are. The verdict is confirmed for real phenomena with an accepted explanation, solved for former puzzles cracked by recent research, and unsolved or unproven where researchers are still arguing about the cause.

  1. S
  2. S
  3. C
  4. C
  5. C
  6. C
  7. C
  8. U
  9. U
  10. U
  • 5 confirmed
  • 2 solved
  • 2 unsolved
  • 1 unproven

Each square is one case, stamped with its verdict. How we decide verdicts

Opened October 12, 202621 sources
Case 1 of 10Racetrack Playa, CaliforniaSolved 2014

Death Valley's Sailing Stones

On a dry lakebed in Death Valley National Park called Racetrack Playa, rocks leave long trails across the flat mud, as if dragged by invisible hands. The tracks have been documented since 1948, yet for decades no one had ever seen a rock actually move. Theories ranged from hurricane winds on slick mud to sheets of ice to stranger ideas.

In 2013 a team including Richard Norris, James Norris and Ralph Lorenz put out GPS-tagged rocks, a weather station and time-lapse cameras. They got lucky. On December 20, 2013, they watched more than 60 rocks move in a single event.

The answer was thin ice. After winter rain left a shallow pond on the playa, a skin of ice only about 3 to 6 millimeters thick (roughly an eighth to a quarter of an inch) formed overnight. When the morning sun broke it into large floating panels, light winds of about 10 miles per hour pushed the panels, and the panels pushed the rocks across the soft mud underneath. The rocks crept along at just a few yards per minute, slow enough that a visitor might not notice. One GPS-tagged rock of about 34 pounds moved roughly 130 feet in about 12 minutes. The team published its observations in PLOS ONE in August 2014.

SOLVED

Verdict: SolvedGPS-tracked rocks and time-lapse footage published in 2014 showed wind-driven sheets of thin ice push the stones.

Sources (2)
Case 2 of 10Taylor Glacier, AntarcticaDiscovered 1911

Blood Falls

At the snout of Taylor Glacier in Antarctica's McMurdo Dry Valleys, a blood-red stain spills down the white ice and onto frozen Lake Bonney. The Australian geologist Griffith Taylor came across it in 1911, and early explorers assumed the color came from red algae.

It does not. In the 1960s, researchers showed the stain is iron. Beneath the glacier, under roughly 1,300 feet (400 meters) of ice, sits a pool of ancient brine, likely seawater trapped millions of years ago when the advancing glacier sealed off an inlet. As water froze out, the remaining brine grew so salty, about two to three times saltier than the ocean, that it stays liquid at around 19 degrees Fahrenheit (minus 7 Celsius). The brine is rich in dissolved iron. When it seeps out and meets the air, the iron oxidizes, essentially rusting, and paints the ice red.

The surprise came later. In 2009, a team led by Jill Mikucki reported in Science that the brine holds a community of microbes living with almost no oxygen and no sunlight, surviving on iron and sulfate compounds. The reservoir may have been sealed off for 1.5 to 2 million years, making it a kind of biological time capsule.

SOLVED

Verdict: SolvedThe red color is oxidized iron from ancient subglacial brine, not algae; research since the 1960s has confirmed the chemistry.

Sources (2)
Case 3 of 10Polar seasFilmed 2011

Brinicles

In 2011, a camera crew for the BBC series Frozen Planet filmed something that looked like a special effect: a hollow tube of ice growing downward from the underside of Antarctic sea ice, reaching the seabed and then spreading across it like a frozen web, trapping sea stars and sea urchins in its path. Scientists call it a brinicle.

The physics is surprisingly tidy. When seawater freezes, the salt does not fit into the ice crystals, so it is squeezed out into pockets of very cold, very salty brine. That brine is denser than the surrounding seawater, so when it leaks out through cracks it sinks as a plume. Because it is colder than the normal freezing point of seawater, the ordinary water it touches freezes around it, building a fragile ice sheath that grows downward as the brine keeps flowing.

Brinicles have been known since the 1960s, and oceanographer Seelye Martin described the standard model for how they form in 1974. Researchers have since compared them to chemical gardens and to undersea hydrothermal vents working in reverse, and some have suggested that the brine channels inside sea ice could have offered chemical conditions useful to early life. The Frozen Planet footage was simply the first time anyone captured one forming on camera.

CONFIRMED

Verdict: ConfirmedBrinicles are a well-understood result of brine rejection in freezing seawater, first filmed forming in 2011.

Sources (2)
Case 4 of 10Gulf of Carpentaria, AustraliaLate September to early November

The Morning Glory Cloud

Imagine a single tube-shaped cloud stretching from horizon to horizon, rolling toward you at dawn like a giant rolling pin. That is the Morning Glory, a roll cloud that appears over the southern Gulf of Carpentaria in northern Australia with enough regularity that glider pilots travel to the small town of Burketown to ride it.

The clouds can be up to about 620 miles (1,000 kilometers) long and often sit only a few hundred feet above the ground. They can move at roughly 20 to 45 miles per hour. Roll clouds form elsewhere, but this is the only place where they can be predicted and seen on a regular basis.

According to Australia's Bureau of Meteorology, the trigger is the geography of the Cape York Peninsula. Sea breezes blowing in from the ocean on each side of the peninsula collide over land during the day. At night, cooler air descends and slides out over the gulf beneath a layer of temperature inversion, setting off a wave in the atmosphere. Moist air condenses into cloud at the rising front of the wave and evaporates at the back, so the cloud seems to roll as it travels. Meteorologists describe it as a solitary wave, a single pulse that can travel a long way without falling apart.

CONFIRMED

Verdict: ConfirmedAustralia's Bureau of Meteorology explains the Morning Glory as an atmospheric wave set off by colliding sea breezes over Cape York.

Sources (2)
Case 5 of 10Coastal waters worldwide, including Southern CaliforniaOngoing

Glowing Waves

On certain nights, breaking waves light up electric blue. Every crash of surf sends a sheet of light racing along the beach, and footprints in the wet sand sparkle. It looks like a lighting effect at a theme park, but it is alive.

The light comes from dinoflagellates, single-celled plankton that drift near the surface. Some species are bioluminescent, and when they bloom in large numbers, the water can glow whenever something disturbs it. A wave, a boat hull or a swimmer's hand is enough. The light comes from a chemical reaction in which a compound called luciferin reacts with oxygen, often sped up by an enzyme called luciferase. The Smithsonian notes that the glow may work as a burglar alarm: a flash when a small predator attacks can draw the attention of a bigger predator that eats the attacker.

In Southern California, the best-known glowing displays come from blooms of a dinoflagellate called Lingulodinium polyedra, which also causes the reddish-brown water known as red tide during the day. The organism runs on a daily clock and glows most strongly at night, which makes it a favorite of scientists who study biological rhythms. Bioluminescence itself is everywhere in the ocean. NOAA estimates that roughly 80 percent of animals living between about 650 and 3,300 feet down can make their own light.

CONFIRMED

Verdict: ConfirmedGlowing surf is bioluminescence from dinoflagellate blooms, a well-documented chemical reaction triggered by motion.

Sources (3)
Case 6 of 10Erupting volcanoes worldwideRecorded since AD 79

Volcanic Lightning

Photographs of erupting volcanoes sometimes show forks of lightning crackling through the ash cloud, as if a thunderstorm had been stuffed inside an explosion. The earliest written description comes from Pliny the Younger, who saw lightning in the dark cloud over Mount Vesuvius in AD 79.

The basic cause is the same as in a thunderstorm: electrical charges get separated until the air can no longer hold them apart and a spark jumps. The question has been where the charge comes from. Two studies published in 2016 in Geophysical Research Letters helped answer it. A team led by Alexa Van Eaton of the US Geological Survey studied the April 2015 eruption of Calbuco in Chile and found that in big eruptions, lightning followed the high, drifting ash plume, pointing to ice crystals forming in the cold upper cloud, just as in ordinary storms.

A second team, led by Corrado Cimarelli of Ludwig Maximilian University in Munich, recorded lightning at Sakurajima in Japan. There, sparks near the vent came from ash and rock fragments colliding and rubbing together, building up static charge with no ice needed. Shattering rock may also release charge right at the vent. So volcanic lightning comes in more than one kind, which helps explain why it can appear both low in the plume and high in the ash cloud.

CONFIRMED

Verdict: ConfirmedField studies show volcanic lightning comes from charge built up by colliding ash particles and, in tall plumes, by ice.

Sources (2)
Case 7 of 10Lake Maracaibo, VenezuelaOngoing

Catatumbo Lightning

Where the Catatumbo River empties into Lake Maracaibo in western Venezuela, thunderstorms build on so many nights a year that sailors once used them as a lighthouse. Locals call it the Beacon of Maracaibo. The lightning shows up in a 1597 poem by Lope de Vega and appears on the flag of the Venezuelan state of Zulia.

The numbers are startling. The Lake Maracaibo basin averages about 250 lightning flashes per square kilometer a year (roughly 650 per square mile), which Columbia University's International Research Institute for Climate and Society describes as the highest annual lightning rate anywhere on Earth. Estimates of how many nights it storms vary widely between sources, from about 140 to 260 a year, often for hours at a stretch.

The explanation is geography. The basin is hemmed in by the Andes and the Perijá Mountains. Warm, moist air from the Caribbean and the lake gets trapped and pushed upward when it meets the mountains and cooler air flowing down from them, building towering storm clouds night after night. A daily wind pattern called the Maracaibo Basin Low-Level Jet helps regulate the activity. An older idea that methane from swamps and oil fields fuels the storms is disputed, though some researchers think it may play a small role. The lightning can fade during droughts: in early 2010 it went quiet for weeks, setting off rumors it was gone for good, before returning.

CONFIRMED

Verdict: ConfirmedSatellite data confirm the world's highest lightning density over Lake Maracaibo, driven by trapped moist air and surrounding mountains.

Sources (3)
Case 8 of 10WorldwideRecorded for centuries

Raining Animals

Frogs falling from the sky sounds like a biblical plague or a tall tale, and plenty of the old reports probably are tall tales. But some are well documented. The Library of Congress lists frogs falling on Kansas City in 1873, frogs reportedly frozen inside hailstones in Dubuque, Iowa, in 1882, and fish that fell on Marksville, Louisiana, in 1947, which a biologist gathered from the streets. More recent cases include thousands of frogs during a windstorm in Odzaci, Serbia, in 2005 and hundreds of small fish called spangled perch in Lajamanu, in Australia's Northern Territory, in 2010.

The leading explanation is waterspouts, tornadoes that form over or cross water. Their spinning winds can suck up water along with whatever is swimming near the surface, carry it some distance and drop it when the storm weakens. Some scientists suggest any strong storm updraft could do the same with small, light creatures.

The catch is that, as the Library of Congress notes, no one has actually seen a storm lift frogs into the sky, so the evidence is circumstantial. Falls tend to involve one kind of creature of similar size, which fits wind sorting objects by weight. Skeptics also note that many falls may really be animals already on the ground, flushed out by heavy rain, that people assumed came from above.

UNPROVEN

Verdict: UnprovenAnimal falls are documented, and waterspouts are the likely cause, but no one has directly observed the lift-and-drop process.

Sources (1)
Case 9 of 10Hessdalen valley, NorwayReported since the 1930s; peak 1981–1984

The Hessdalen Lights

In a quiet valley in central Norway, about 7.5 miles (12 kilometers) long, residents have reported strange floating lights since at least the 1930s. Between December 1981 and mid-1984, the sightings exploded to 15 to 20 a week. Some hovered for long periods; others moved quickly across the valley. Tourists began camping overnight to see them.

Unlike most light legends, this one attracted sustained research. Project Hessdalen began in 1983, and in 1998 an automated measurement station with cameras and instruments was installed in the valley. Researchers from Norway's Østfold University College and Italy's National Research Council have studied the lights in field campaigns. Sightings have since dropped sharply, to roughly 10 to 20 a year by 2010.

No explanation has won general agreement. Proposals include dust from local mines burning in the air, glowing plasma linked to radon decay, electrical charges from strained quartz-bearing rock, and a 2014 idea that the valley acts like a giant battery, with its two rock walls as electrodes and the river as the electrolyte. Skeptics, including the Skeptoid podcast's Brian Dunning, argue that many recorded lights match aircraft landing lights on a regional flight corridor and car headlights on a nearby highway. Some sightings clearly are mundane. Whether all of them are remains an open question.

UNSOLVED

Verdict: UnsolvedDecades of instrument data confirm unusual lights, but neither exotic physics nor ordinary aircraft and cars have been shown to explain them all.

Sources (2)
Case 10 of 10WorldwideReported for centuries

Ball Lightning

On October 21, 1638, during a violent storm, a ball of fire reportedly entered the parish church at Widecombe-in-the-Moor in Devon, England, killing four people and injuring dozens. Witnesses described a sulfurous smell. It is one of the most famous early accounts of ball lightning: glowing spheres, usually about the size of a grapefruit, that appear during thunderstorms and last from about a second to more than a minute, far longer than an ordinary lightning flash.

Because it cannot be produced on demand, it has been notoriously hard to study. Witnesses are not rare, though: a 1960 survey of employees at Oak Ridge, Tennessee, found a few percent said they had seen one. Then in July 2012, Chinese researchers studying ordinary lightning on the Qinghai Plateau happened to catch a natural ball with their spectrometers. It glowed for about a second roughly 900 meters (about half a mile) away, and its light showed silicon, iron and calcium, elements common in soil.

That fits a leading idea from 2000: that lightning striking the ground vaporizes silica in the soil, which condenses into a glowing cloud of tiny particles that burn slowly as they react with oxygen. Other theories involve trapped microwaves or electrical discharges, and lab experiments have made glowing orbs several ways. But the 2012 recording is a single event, and lightning experts caution it does not settle which theory is right.

UNSOLVED

Verdict: UnsolvedBall lightning has now been recorded by instruments, but no explanation of what causes it is accepted by scientists.

Sources (2)

Nature does not care whether its tricks sound plausible. The sailing stones waited 65 years for the right camera, and ball lightning is still waiting for its explanation.

Which case is the strangest?

Cast your vote to see how everyone else ruled.

Think you'd ace the quiz?

Try the Science Trivia Questions on our sister site, QuizPlays.

Play the quiz

Pass this file along

Know someone who'd argue with a verdict?